By Jordan Robertson, Associated Press
USA Today
Retrieved March 16, 2009
Go to Original Article

Researchers from U.K.-based security firm Prevx found one such trove, a website used as a stash house for data from 160,000 infected computers before it was shut down this month.

The find offers a case study on just how much data criminals are stealing every day, from the utterly inconsequential to the alarmingly private.

It also shows the difficulty in shuttering criminals' ID-theft beachheads: The website that Prevx found, which was operating on a server in Ukraine, was still online for nearly a month after security researchers alerted the Internet service provider and law-enforcement authorities. The site was sucking up data from 5,000 newly infected computers each day.

The victims in the Prevx find are mostly everyday people handing over their passwords for Facebook and banking sites, along with their love notes and other e-mails. But more dangerous personal information is there, too, including Social Security numbers and other account information from one bank's infected computer.

Caches of stolen data like these are hidden throughout the Internet, usually locked away inside password-protected websites or heavily fortified servers. Prevx's researchers were able to infiltrate this site because it was protected with poor encryption.

In that sense, the find illustrates how even sloppy crooks can vacuum up enormous amounts of information through massive "botnets" — armies of infected computers formed by spreading a computer virus that orders compromised machines to phone home for further instructions, such as sending out spam or relaying passwords.

The botnet Prevx found was only harvesting data, though Prevx said it could have been upgraded to do other things.

Ordinary Internet sessions are logged in great detail. One Southern California 22-year-old could be seen registering a domain name with GoDaddy.com, changing his Yahoo e-mail password and ordering a meal online from Pizza Hut. His credit card number, birth date, telephone number, address and passwords are now all in criminals' hands, though it's unclear what, if anything, criminals have done with the information yet.

Some victims are gold mines for sensitive data. An infected computer at a Georgia bank exposed customer details and credentials for the bank's wire-transfer system. Bank employees were checking e-mail, looking up BMWs and Infinitis and working with customers' accounts on the same infected machine.

Government computers were also hit, including one in Texas that coughed up website logins for one of the government's health care providers, and another in North Carolina that revealed access to an agency's human resources system.

"This is giving criminals the keys to the castle," said Prevx's director of malware research, Jacques Erasmus. "Once they're into this system, it might not seem at this point like it's the biggest data heist ever, but this is how they get into a network. This is their game — they do this every day."

In other words, criminals start small, then use their first point of attack as a way to jump onto more sensitive computers.

Researchers who discover these stolen-data caches then have to figure out what to do with them. Notifying victims is time-consuming and difficult, and researchers tend to focus on trying to get service providers to deactivate the servers before criminals get to the data on them.

Prevx said it alerted the site's Internet provider, the FBI and U.K. authorities about the breach it discovered. The company also talked to the affected bank, Doraville, Ga.-based Metro City Bank, a community bank whose website lists four locations, and Prevx said the bank has removed the infected computer.

One customer — Yoon-Kee Hong, a 22-year-old college student from Suwanee, Ga. — had signed up for an account with Metro City Bank just a month before learning about the breach. He said he had not been alerted by the bank that his Social Security number and other personal details were stolen.

After being told about the breach by The Associated Press, which picked his name from the files provided by Prevx, the student said he planned to cancel his account.

"I cannot trust them any more," he said. "They're not doing what they're supposed to do. They didn't even notify me. It's like they're trying to hide it from their customers."

He later relented and decided to stay with the bank after he was offered a new account and promises of fraud alerts.

The bank said in a statement that it is notifying customers and is investigating the breach, refusing to comment further. State officials in North Carolina and Texas didn't return calls on the breaches there. The FBI didn't return a call about the breaches.

Such finds are becoming more common as the barrier lowers for crooks to jump into the online identity-theft racket. Top-of-the-line viruses, also known as Trojans, can be had for under $1,000.

Joe Stewart, a SecureWorks Inc. botnet expert who was not involved in Prevx's research, said that last year, he helped shut down a command-and-control server for a huge botnet that had infected more than 378,000 machines and had stolen more than 460,000 usernames and passwords.

There are countless other smaller botnets, set up by less sophisticated criminals who steal as much data as they can and simply pull up stakes, and do it all over again, once their operation has been detected.

"The level of amateurness speaks to how widespread it is," Stewart said. "Literally anybody with a little bit of computer knowledge at all, if they have the criminal bent, can get access to one of these Trojans and get it out there and start stealing people's data."